I did answer your question, I said we need to give the current system a chance to work before changing it.
The players are still trying to master what Critch is asking of them, i don't see the point of throwing in the towel on this after 4 league games, especially when one of them was a victory and 2 were decided by individual error brain farts in the opening minutes which changed the flow of the rest of those games.
I'm sure Monday to Friday Critch is working on this and maybe even tweaking things to pull it all together, but this is a work in progress, and it must be afforded a bit more than 3 league defeats before tearing it up and trying something else.
Re Madine, the general feeling was that he was crap, I didn't mean to single out you specifically.
Edit to add: I agree something isn't working, I've said previously that Yates doesn't seem to fit the role he is being asked to play. I actually have more concerns with the midfield than the front 3, where we seem to be carrying a player who isn't contributing. This is what I feel Critch will be working on, I certainly hope he is; Ward has been a passenger too often this season and needs to either get involved more or someone else needs to be given a chance.