Is it time to end penalty shoot outs

[tangerinespud]

Going way back to school days …. Our school games always had the rule that first goal only count as a half goal. No games were ever a draw except if it was goal less

 

[Trammo]

Withdraw both keepers for extra time. If still deadlocked a pen shootout with an outfield player in goal.

 

[Pauls_Boutique]

Can’t do replays these days as fixtures are so congested already. Plus can you imagine the cost for Rangers & Frankfurt fans to fly out to Seville again next week.

There is no realistic alternative so I’d keep it as it is for finals, but for 2 legs I’d bin off extra time. If you can’t separate teams after 2 games I don’t see any point in playing for an extra half hour.

 

[Lytham_fy8]

A quick game of double cuppies, obviously take the goalposts down and replace with jumpers, use a 99p plastic ball for top corner swerve shots, replace all boots with Kenyons 'two stripe' specials, sprinkle a bit of glass on the pitch and have the team's mums telling them to come in as it's going dark.

 

[EagleDay]

Penalty Corners.

Each team takes it in turn to take a corner, after three touches the ball is declared dead. Fouls by the defending team result in a penalty. Sudden death right from the start, first to score wins. Starting team decided by a coin toss.
That way, every member of the team is involved throughout, so no single hero/villain.

I like that one.

 

[Lytham_fy8]

I like that one.

It would go one for DAYS.

 

[poolseasider]

They used to in the past when transport wasn't what it is now.

When was that nearly 50 years ago?

 

[Macseasider]

A quick game of double cuppies, obviously take the goalposts down and replace with jumpers, use a 99p plastic ball for top corner swerve shots, replace all boots with Kenyons 'two stripe' specials, sprinkle a bit of glass on the pitch and have the team's mums telling them to come in as it's going dark.

Need a few "white" dog turds spotted about too.

 

[SwannDangerous]

Maybe it would be fairer if all 11 players have to take one instead of limiting it to just 5 players. Then it would be a reflection of the whole team's effort.

Actually really like that idea, best of 11 kind of scenario

 

[SwannDangerous]

It should be done on tournament points, if equal, total goals scored, if equal, total goals conceded, if equal then pens or golden dribbles from the half way line.

Anything like this just ensights a draw fest from the team that's got more of the aforementioned stats.

 

[fcblackpool]

Anything like this just ensights a draw fest from the team that's got more of the aforementioned stats.

Yeah, I agree. I updated with another post today. No change for me. They know the rules, they should prepare for the implementation of the rules.

 

[20togo]

to be honest, not sure there is anything better than as it is. The only thing that I could suggest is that penalties are a confidence thing as well as pressure and some players thrive on it. So each team names their eleven players in the order they will take a penalty and then it's sudden death straight from the off. So the most confident player will take the first penalty and the responsibility of missing.

 

[Beedar]

Is it just me or when it comes to penalties, the team I want to win always loses, it must av happened to me about 30 times on the run now ?

 

[LimerickTangerine]

The pressure on the players these days is immense and if unsuccessful, leaves them open to the sort of sh*t we saw after last night.

After extra time, if the scores are level, the winner could be the team with most shots on target, or corners won....

Thoughts?

No way

Penalty shoot outs are amazing
Bummer if on the losing end, fantastic for both winning side & neutral viewers

 

[archie]

to be honest, not sure there is anything better than as it is. The only thing that I could suggest is that penalties are a confidence thing as well as pressure and some players thrive on it. So each team names their eleven players in the order they will take a penalty and then it's sudden death straight from the off. So the most confident player will take the first penalty and the responsibility of missing.

I quite like this idea.

 

[Adams Kebab]

The pressure on the players these days is immense and if unsuccessful, leaves them open to the sort of sh*t we saw after last night.

After extra time, if the scores are level, the winner could be the team with most shots on target, or corners won....

Thoughts?

One of the worst ideas I’ve ever heard.

Elite sportsmen under pressure… shall we rule a goal out if they slip or the keeper drops one? Maybe give a goal if a player misses an open net.

I don’t know if people are joking anymore.

 

[Lytham_fy8]

Is it just me or when it comes to penalties, the team I want to win always loses, it must av happened to me about 30 times on the run now ?

England 2018?